A machine that stands still for an hour has cost you something. Most owners feel it, and few have a number. This piece gives you a way to work out your own number in rupees. Then it sets out what published research says about how much time factories lose, and what watching the machines is worth. Every figure comes from a source we have read, named and linked at the end. They are findings about this kind of system, not a promise about Blitz.
What does one hour of a stopped machine cost?
Take a machine that makes 40 units an hour of a product that sells at ₹12. Each unit takes ₹7.00 of raw material and ₹0.50 of power.
One stopped hour, in rupees
- Sales not made: 40 units × ₹12 = ₹480
- Raw material not used: 40 × ₹7.00 = ₹280
- Power not used: 40 × ₹0.50 = ₹20
- Lost contribution: ₹480 less ₹280 less ₹20 = ₹180
- Inside that ₹180: the operator's pay for the hour, ₹80, and the hour's share of rent, salaries and interest, ₹50. Both kept running. The last ₹50 is profit you did not earn.
So the hour cost ₹180: ₹130 of costs that kept running with nothing to show for them, and ₹50 of profit. Lose one such hour a day on ten machines over 26 working days and that is 260 hours, or ₹46,800 a month.
One caution. This is the cost when you could have sold what the machine would have made. If there was no order waiting, the hour cost less.
How much time do factories lose to downtime?
More than most owners would guess.
Researchers at Chalmers University of Technology in Sweden analysed 94 sets of OEE figures from manufacturers. OEE is the share of planned time a machine spends making good product at full speed (see the glossary). The average was 51.5%, against the 85% usually called world class. Unplanned stops averaged 9.6% of scheduled time, and setups 11.5%.
In the United States, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) surveyed manufacturers about maintenance. The quarter of plants that relied most on repairing machines after they broke had 13.0% downtime. The quarter that relied on it least had 4.0%. NIST puts the gap at 3.28 times.
What do published figures say a stopped hour costs?
An earlier NIST study of small and medium manufacturers drew a typical medium-sized contract manufacturer, with 150 employees, from its case studies. Its machines cost it $225 an hour on average when they were down.
The NIST survey also put a national number on it. In 2016, maintenance problems that could have been prevented cost US discrete manufacturers $18.1 billion in downtime, and $100.2 billion in sales lost to delays and defects. The lost sales were more than five times the cost of the idle time. For a small factory the lesson is the same: the wages wasted in a stopped hour are the small part. The order that went late is the big one.
What is machine monitoring worth? Three findings
Short stops are invisible until a machine records them
A two-year study by researchers in Poland recorded every short stop on three machines automatically. The authors report that the stops could hardly be noticed during production, and that only automatic recording showed how large they were. Short stops cut performance by 3 to 6% on every machine tested.
Many factories still collect no machine data
A 2022 UNIDO survey of 63 Indian automotive component makers, run with the industry body ACMA, found that over 36% used no technology at all to collect machine or operating data. Around 23% had sensors sending production status in real time. The earlier NIST study cites an expert estimate that only 5% of machines in factories are monitored digitally.
One company case in the UNIDO report, a firm of 500 to 999 employees, put its machines on real-time monitoring alongside other changes and reported a 30% improvement in OEE. That is one firm reporting on itself. Read it as an example, not an average.
Recording a stop is not enough: it needs a reason
A Swedish study looked at 884 machines in 23 companies that already measured OEE automatically. The average OEE was 65%. But the cause of about half of the lost time could not be classified, because the stops had no usable reason against them. Of the stop time that did have a reason, about 90% came from supporting work done by operators, not from the machine's own process.
What the research does not say
Be careful with these numbers. Most come from the United States and Europe, and from plants larger than a 30-machine unit. Surveys rely on what companies say about themselves. And no study here says that a sensor on a machine raises output by itself. The gain comes when somebody acts on what was recorded: the stop that keeps coming back, the setup that takes twice as long on one shift.
What to do with this
Work out your own stopped hour with the sum above. Then find out how many hours you lose, and why. That second part is what machine monitoring is for. Blitz catches each stop as it happens, a person tags the reason, and each lost hour is priced from your own cost: see downtime and OEE. To price an hour you first need the cost of a unit: how to find the true cost per unit.
Sources
- Thomas, D. and Weiss, B. (2020). Economics of Manufacturing Machinery Maintenance: A Survey and Analysis of U.S. Costs and Benefits. NIST Advanced Manufacturing Series 100-34, National Institute of Standards and Technology.
- Helu, M. and Weiss, B. (2016). The Current State of Sensing, Health Management, and Control for Small-to-Medium-Sized Manufacturers. ASME Manufacturing Science and Engineering Conference, National Institute of Standards and Technology.
- Gopalakrishnan, M. (2018). Data-Driven Decision Support for Maintenance Prioritisation: Connecting Maintenance to Productivity. Doctoral thesis, Chalmers University of Technology. It reports the OEE study by Ylipää, Skoogh, Bokrantz and Gopalakrishnan (2017), International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 66(1).
- Hedman, R., Subramaniyan, M. and Almström, P. (2016). Analysis of Critical Factors for Automatic Measurement of OEE. Procedia CIRP, 57, pages 128 to 133.
- United Nations Industrial Development Organization (2022). Assessment of the application of Industry 4.0 and digitalization in the context of automotive component manufacturing in India. Published with ACMA; copy hosted by the Ministry of Heavy Industries, Government of India.
- Hubicki, R., Richert, M., Łebkowski, P. and Hubicka, N. (2020). Impact of Micro-Stoppages on Overall Equipment Effectiveness Measure. Zarządzanie Przedsiębiorstwem (Enterprise Management), 23(1), pages 10 to 15.